Who should sing Sweet Child of Mine?

Fergie

Axl

Photo by kindofadraag

Photo by Edvill

Background:

posted 02-06-2011 by Jon

111115

view results

Fergie sounded pretty awesome during the halftime show, but was she better than Axl?

Debate It! 11

Umm... no. She looks more like a man though.

Posted By SimpleDude, 02-06-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

My brain "Really, good for her. Maybe I should go check this out. Here's a clip. Oh Slash is up there. This might actually be OMYGAWD WHY IS SHE GRUNTING LIKE THAT?"

Seriously. Fuck you Will.i.am for making a speedfreak groupie your lead singer and turning your group into a soulless money machine.

So. I guess I'd say Axl.

Posted By Actionamy, 02-06-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

the black eye peas cant sing live and sound even halfway like their cd. as a person from a musical background i can honestly say we musicians have no respect for those that can only sing with the help of auto tune. we understand that it wont sound exactly like the cd but it needs to be at least 3/4 of the way close.

Posted By meganlavada, 02-06-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

It's funny because I actually logged on to ask which was more disappointing - the surprisingly crappy commercials or Fergie's surprisingly bad performance of "Sweet Child o' Mine." For me personally, it was Fergie's craptastic mutilation of a rock classic; it was so bad it actually made me miss Janet Jackson's nipple piercing.

Posted By Cobanerd, 02-06-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

Is it all the steroids she has taken or what, but girl sounds friggin awful.

Posted By AnubisibunA, 02-07-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

Fergie should go die in a fire. WORST HALFTIME SHOW EVER!

Posted By AlabamaMourning, 02-07-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

Halftime show, you called it that!? no, no, no,! It was halftime squealfest!

Posted By Mr.Truther, 02-08-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

I'll take a sweaty, puffy Axl Rose over the Black Eyed Peas any day.

Posted By Rebecca, 02-08-2011 (1 years and 3 months)

Her rendition was okay; it sounded better than her own songs because those sounded GOD AWFUL. However, compared to Axl singing it there's simply no comparison. Axl sounds better by far.

Posted By bears8989, 02-08-2011 (1 years and 3 months)